Quick answer: An ash tree has branches and buds in opposite pairs, compound leaves with 5 to 11 leaflets, and (on mature trees) tight bark with diamond-shaped ridges. A tree in Ohio that passes all three checks is very likely an ash, which means emerald ash borer is a concern.
Before you spend money on treatment or removal, make sure the tree is an ash. The checks below come from Michigan State University (MSU) Extension, the Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR) and Purdue University, and you can do all of them from the ground. If your tree is an ash and already dying, see ash tree removal.
What three checks settle it?
MSU Extension’s ash tree identification bulletin lists the features that separate ash from other yard trees. Use all three together, because one feature on its own can mislead you.
| Check | What to look for | The catch |
|---|---|---|
| Branching | Branches, twigs and buds sit directly across from each other | Some buds and limbs die, so not every branch has a partner |
| Leaves | Compound leaf with 5 to 11 leaflets | Leaflet edges can be smooth or toothed |
| Bark | Tight bark with diamond-shaped ridges | Young trees have fairly smooth bark |
How do you identify an ash tree by leaf?
An ash leaf is compound: one leaf is made of several leaflets attached to a central stalk. Count the leaflets on a few leaves. Ash has 5 to 11, and the whole leaf is about 8 to 12 inches long according to a second MSU Extension bulletin on telling ash from other trees.
ODNR’s white ash page narrows it for that species: 5 to 9 leaflets, usually seven or nine, dark green on top and whitish green underneath. The leaves themselves are attached in opposite pairs along the twig.
How do you identify an ash tree by bark?
On a mature ash, the bark is tight to the trunk and the ridges cross to form a diamond pattern. ODNR describes it as interlacing ridges and furrows, and says mature white ash and green ash bark look the same.
Bark is the weakest check on a young tree. Purdue University’s ash identification page notes that the diamond pattern may not show on young trees. For those, rely on branching and leaves.
What does opposite branching look like?
Stand back and follow one branch outward. On an ash, side branches and buds leave the stem in pairs, one straight across from the other. Purdue puts it simply: if the branches are staggered or alternate, the tree is not an ash.
Look at several branches before deciding, since dead buds and lost limbs can leave gaps.
How do you identify an ash tree in winter?
You can identify an ash without leaves. Opposite branching and bark are visible all year, and the twigs add more clues:
- Buds: paired along the twig, with a single bud at the tip (MSU Extension).
- Leaf scars: the mark left where a leaf fell. MSU describes the white ash scar as a C turned on its side and the green ash scar as a D on its side, like a smile. ODNR calls the white ash scar U-shaped, with a bud sitting in the curve.
- Twigs: gray to brown with no waxy coating. ODNR describes white ash twigs as stout.
- Seeds: dry, oar-shaped winged seeds that hang in clusters and often stay on into late fall or early winter. ODNR notes they form on female trees, and MSU says many ash cultivars are seedless, so a tree without seeds can still be an ash.
Which trees look like ash?
Boxelder is the closest lookalike because it also has opposite branching. The others fail the branching check. These differences come from the two MSU Extension bulletins.
| Tree | Branching | Leaflets per leaf | What gives it away |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ash | Opposite | 5 to 11 | Single oar-shaped seeds in clusters, diamond bark when mature |
| Boxelder | Opposite | 3 to 5 | Seeds always in pairs; green to purplish twigs with a waxy white coating that rubs off |
| Black walnut | Alternate | 9 to 15 | Leaves 15 to 24 inches long; large nut in a green husk |
| Shagbark hickory | Alternate | 5 to 7 | Bark in long, loose strips; hard-shelled nuts |
| Mountainash | Alternate | 9 to 15 | White flower clusters in May, red-orange berries in fall |
| Elm | Alternate | Not compound | Single toothed leaves with an uneven base |
What should you do if it is an ash?
Assume it is at risk. ODNR states that emerald ash borer attacks all of Ohio’s native ash species and that the first Ohio discovery was in Lucas County in February 2003. Our guide to emerald ash borer in Toledo covers the local history.
Then check the tree’s condition. Purdue lists dieback in the upper canopy, vertical bark splits, D-shaped exit holes, bark stripped by woodpeckers and sprouts at the base of the trunk as signs of attack. How much healthy canopy is left decides whether to treat or remove an ash.
Ash tree identification FAQs
How do I identify an ash tree without leaves?
Look for buds and branches in opposite pairs, a single bud at the tip of each twig, and leaf scars shaped like a C or D on its side. On a mature trunk the diamond-ridged bark confirms it.
Is a boxelder an ash tree?
No. MSU Extension notes that boxelder shares the opposite branching and compound leaves, but it usually has only 3 to 5 leaflets and its winged seeds always come in pairs. Its twigs are green to purplish with a waxy coating, while ash twigs are gray to brown.
Is mountain ash a true ash?
No. MSU Extension points out that mountainash and prickly ash carry the name but are not true ash, and only true ash species are susceptible to emerald ash borer.
Sources
- Michigan State University Extension: Ash Tree Identification, Bulletin E-2942
- Michigan State University Extension (copy hosted by Waterford Township): Distinguishing Ash from Other Common Trees, Bulletin E-2892
- Ohio Department of Natural Resources: White Ash (Fraxinus americana)
- Purdue University Extension Entomology: Emerald Ash Borer Identification