Quick answer: Treatment is worth considering when the ash is still healthy, has lost less than about 30 percent of its canopy and is a tree you value. Extension researchers say it is probably too late once more than half the canopy is gone. Treatment has to be repeated for as long as you keep the tree, and in Ohio anyone you hire to apply it needs a state license.
This site’s business does not sell insecticide treatment, so this guide sets out both options as extension services describe them. If you already know the tree has to go, see ash tree removal and replacement. For why every ash in the area is exposed, read emerald ash borer in Toledo.
What is the short answer?
Canopy condition decides it. Stand back and estimate how much of the crown is thin or dead compared with a full, healthy tree.
| Condition of the ash | What extension sources advise |
|---|---|
| Full canopy, good structure, a tree you value | Good candidate for treatment |
| Less than 30 percent canopy loss | Have a professional protect it (Purdue) |
| 30 to 50 percent canopy loss | Sources differ. Purdue says plan removal above 30 percent; others still allow treatment up to about 50 percent |
| More than 50 percent canopy loss | Remove (University of Wisconsin Extension, multi-state bulletin) |
| Dead, structurally damaged or badly placed | Remove |
The 30 percent figure is from the Purdue Landscape Report. The 50 percent figure is from Insecticide Options for Protecting Ash Trees from Emerald Ash Borer, a multi-state bulletin published by the North Central IPM Center.
When does treatment make sense?
When the tree can still move water. The bulletin explains that most products are systemic: they travel up through the tree’s water-conducting tissue to the canopy. Borer damage blocks that tissue, so a badly infested tree cannot carry the product where it is needed. Insecticide stops further damage but does not reverse what is done.
Product choice matters too. In the bulletin’s trials, emamectin benzoate injected into the trunk gave up to three years of control from one spring application and outperformed the other systemic products. Dinotefuran needs yearly application, azadirachtin lasts one to two years, and soil-applied imidacloprid gave inconsistent results.
University of Wisconsin Extension suggests weighing the tree’s value: its health, shape, shade and place in the yard.
When does removal make sense?
When the canopy is past the threshold, or the tree was never a good one. Wisconsin Extension lists disease, poor shape, structural damage and a bad location, such as near a power line, as reasons a tree is a poor candidate for treatment.
Timing matters once you choose removal. Purdue Extension advises taking ash down before it dies or loses major limbs, because dead ash turns brittle and is much harder to cut down safely. If you cannot judge the canopy from the ground, an arborist inspection gives you a firm answer. After removal, see trees to plant in place of ash.
What does each choice cost over ten years?
The business has no published prices and does not offer treatment, so these are third-party figures as of October 2026. The ten-year column is simple arithmetic on those figures. An on-site quote is the only real price.
| Option | Published figure | Over ten years |
|---|---|---|
| Homeowner soil drench, trunk about 10 inches across | $20 to $50 per year (Wisconsin Extension) | $200 to $500 |
| Professional treatment | Often $200 or more each time (Wisconsin Extension) | $800 to $1,000 or more, for four or five treatments |
| Removing a small ash under 25 feet | Several hundred dollars (Wisconsin Extension) | Paid once, plus replanting |
| Removing a larger ash | $1,000 or more (Wisconsin Extension); $250 to $1,800 national range (HomeAdvisor) | Paid once, plus replanting |
Four or five treatments assumes a trunk injection every two to three years. The HomeAdvisor range is from its national tree removal cost guide.
The multi-state bulletin reports that multiple studies found treating landscape ash costs much less than removing it. The catch is that treatment does not end at year ten, while removal is a one-time cost.
Who can treat ash trees in Ohio?
A licensed commercial applicator, or you on your own tree. Ohio Revised Code section 921.06 requires a commercial applicator license, issued by the director of agriculture, to apply pesticides for a pesticide business. Ohio State’s Pesticide Safety Education Program confirms this covers anyone applying pesticides to another person’s property for hire. Ask to see the license before work starts.
Homeowners may treat their own trees with retail products if they follow the label. Wisconsin Extension suggests that approach only for trees up to about 15 inches in trunk diameter, and says trees of 20 inches or more should be treated by a professional. Emamectin benzoate is a professional product.
Treat or remove ash FAQs
Is it too late to treat my ash tree?
Probably, if more than half the canopy is dead or missing. Below that, treatment can stop further damage, but the multi-state bulletin is clear that it cannot bring dead branches back.
How often does an ash tree need treatment?
Every one to three years, depending on the product. The bulletin found spring applications consistently more effective than fall ones, with trunk injections best made from mid-May to mid-June in the upper Midwest.
Do I have to treat the tree forever?
Plan on it. Purdue’s emerald ash borer FAQ advises treating until nearby untreated ash have died and then watching closely. The bulletin says treatments may later be spaced further apart, but only with monitoring.
Sources
- North Central IPM Center (copy hosted by the New Jersey Department of Agriculture): Insecticide Options for Protecting Ash Trees from Emerald Ash Borer, Third Edition
- Purdue Landscape Report: Avoid Deadly Risk of Dying Ash Trees with Timely Tree Removal
- University of Wisconsin Extension: Is My Ash Tree Worth Treating for Emerald Ash Borer?
- Purdue University Extension Entomology: Emerald Ash Borer Management
- Purdue University Extension Entomology: Emerald Ash Borer FAQ
- HomeAdvisor: How Much Does Tree Removal Cost?
- Ohio Revised Code: Section 921.06, Commercial applicator license
- Ohio State University Pesticide Safety Education Program: Commercial Applicator brochure