Best Trees to Replace Ash in Northwest Ohio

No single tree should replace ash. Ohio State Extension lists bur oak, swamp white oak, hackberry, Kentucky coffeetree and others. Mix species and match the site.
Get a Free Estimate

Tell us what you need and we will call you back.

By sending this form you agree to our Privacy Policy.

PK Barmon
· 5 min read

Quick answer: There is no single best replacement. Ohio State University Extension’s ash replacement bulletin profiles 35 species, among them bur oak, swamp white oak, hackberry, Kentucky coffeetree and thornless honeylocust for yards and tree lawns. Choose by site, mix species, and skip Callery (Bradford) pear, which has been illegal to sell or plant in Ohio since January 2023.

Every tree named below comes from a published list by Ohio State University Extension, the Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR), Iowa State University Extension or FirstEnergy. We say whose list each one is from. If the old tree is still standing, arrange ash removal before you replant, so the new tree does not go in under a failing one.

Why not replace ash with one species?

Because relying on one kind of tree is how the area lost so much canopy. Metroparks Toledo reports that many of its parks lost nearly all their mature ash by about 2010. Our guide to emerald ash borer in Toledo tells that story.

Iowa State University Extension gives a simple guideline for a yard or neighborhood: no more than 10 percent of trees from one species, 20 percent from one genus and 30 percent from one family. It also warns that maples and oaks are already over-represented in residential areas. Look at what your street has plenty of, then plant something else.

Which large shade trees replace ash well?

These are from Ohio State University Extension Bulletin 924, Ash Replacements for Urban and Woodland Plantings. Each is listed there as a replacement for both open yards and tree lawns.

Tree What the bulletin says
Bur oak Wide soil and pH range, well suited to urban sites; large acorns
Swamp white oak Wide soil range, adapted to urban sites
Chinkapin oak Highly drought tolerant; slow when young
Common hackberry Very tolerant of drought and urban conditions
Kentucky coffeetree Tolerates drought and deicing salt; fruit litter
Thornless honeylocust Tolerates drought, salt and wet soil; stunted where roots are cramped
American elm Very urban tolerant; plant only Dutch elm disease resistant cultivars

The bulletin dates from 2005, so ask the nursery about current pest concerns. It already flags oak wilt as a concern for red oak and scarlet oak. For a wider selection, see the best trees to plant in Northwest Ohio.

Which trees suit a small yard?

The Ohio State bulletin covers full-size trees, so small yards need a different list. ODNR’s Callery pear page names native alternatives to that ornamental, including serviceberry, eastern redbud, flowering dogwood, American hornbeam, eastern hophornbeam, hawthorn, American plum and chokecherry.

Iowa State University Extension lists all eight of those among small ornamental trees under 30 feet tall. ODNR puts flowering dogwood at about 15 feet tall and 20 feet wide, and notes it prefers moist, well-drained, acidic soil.

Which trees handle wet soil?

Many ash stood in low ground. ODNR describes green ash as a tree found mainly in floodplains. For those spots, Ohio State Bulletin 924 describes:

  • Bald cypress: very flood tolerant, but intolerant of deicing salt.
  • Sycamore: very tolerant of wet soils and short-term flooding.
  • Pin oak: flood tolerant; lower branches sweep down and need pruning near walks.
  • Swamp white oak: intermediate flood tolerance.
  • River birch and red maple: suited to wet sites, but both do best in acid soil and can yellow where soil pH is high.

What can you plant under power lines?

Something short, or nothing. FirstEnergy’s tree planting guidance says to avoid planting directly under lines where possible.

Distance from overhead lines FirstEnergy guidance
Within 20 feet Trees that mature at 25 feet or less, such as flowering crabapple, dogwood and serviceberry
20 to 50 feet Trees that mature at 40 feet or less, such as linden and magnolia
50 feet or more Tall trees such as maple and oak

The strip between sidewalk and curb is different. The City of Toledo’s street tree FAQ says City arborists choose and plant street trees on a Right Tree, Right Place basis, and residents cannot pick the species. In your own yard, our tree planting in Toledo page explains how we help.

Which trees can you not plant in Ohio?

Callery pear, including Bradford pear. Ohio Administrative Code rule 901:5-30-01 lists it as an invasive plant that no one may sell, propagate or distribute, and its exemption ended in January 2023. When 13abc reported the coming ban, an Ohio State Extension educator based in Toledo suggested serviceberry as a native substitute.

FirstEnergy also lists trees it does not recommend near overhead lines because of brittleness or pest problems, including silver maple, boxelder, Siberian elm and tree-of-heaven.

Ash replacement FAQs

What are good trees to replace ash trees?

For a full-size shade tree, Ohio State Extension’s list includes bur oak, swamp white oak, hackberry, Kentucky coffeetree and thornless honeylocust. For a small space, ODNR’s native list includes serviceberry, redbud and American hornbeam.

Can I replace an ash with another ash?

It is not a sound choice. ODNR states that emerald ash borer attacks all of Ohio’s native ash species, so a new ash would face the same insect.

Does the City replace ash trees in the tree lawn?

Street trees are the City’s to plant. Its FAQ says planting happens in spring (mid-April to June) and fall (November to December), and that concerns go to Engage Toledo at 419-936-2020.

Sources

Need Help With a Tree?

Tell us about the job and get a free quote from our Toledo team.

Contact Us
PK Barmon
About the author:

PK Barmon researches and writes the tree care guides on Tree Services Toledo Ohio. Every guide is built from primary sources such as Ohio State University Extension, the City of Toledo and Ohio state agencies, and each one lists its sources so you can check them.