Which Trees Fail Most in Northwest Ohio Storms?

We found no published count ranking Toledo storm failures by species. Research rates silver maple, Siberian elm and Bradford pear as ice-prone; decay and weak unions matter on any tree.
Get a Free Estimate

Tell us what you need and we will call you back.

By sending this form you agree to our Privacy Policy.

PK Barmon
· 5 min read

Quick answer: We found no published count of which species failed most in Toledo-area storms, so be wary of any ranked local list. The best-documented list is for ice storms: University of Illinois research rates silver maple, Siberian elm, Bradford pear, green ash, honey locust and several others as susceptible. For wind, the extension sources we checked point to decay, weak branch unions and root problems, not to a species list.

If you have large trees near the house, the useful question is which ones to have looked at first. This guide uses university extension and arborist-association sources and says whose list each one is. If a tree is already down, see our storm damage tree service in Toledo.

What did the June 2023 tornadoes show?

Ten tornadoes touched down across Northwest Ohio and southeast Michigan on the night of 15 June 2023, a count confirmed by the National Weather Service, as 13abc reported. One was an EF-2 with 130 mph winds that struck Toledo’s Point Place and was on the ground for about four minutes. The station reported downed power lines, trees and branches, and more than two dozen poles down in the Point Place area.

That report does not break the tree damage down by species, and we found no study that does. What follows comes from research done elsewhere. As the International Society of Arboriculture (ISA) puts it, there is no such thing as a completely safe tree.

Why do some trees fail first?

Purdue Extension’s Trees and Storms publication describes five ways trees fail: the whole tree is pushed over (wind throw), the trunk fails at its weakest point, a lopsided crown twists the limbs and trunk, damaged roots let the tree lean and fall, or branches break under load.

Condition drives most of these. University of Minnesota Extension calls decayed wood the most common contributor to tree failure. It adds that branches or leaders without a sound union tend to separate during storms, and that a trunk squeezed by girdling roots is often the point of failure in high wind.

Which species have weaker wood or structure?

The clearest published ratings are for ice. They come from University of Illinois researchers (Hauer, Hruska and Dawson), in a fact sheet republished by UNH Cooperative Extension.

Ice storm rating Species on the Illinois list (commonly planted urban trees)
Susceptible American elm, American linden, black cherry, black locust, Bradford pear, common hackberry, green ash, honey locust, pin oak, Siberian elm, silver maple
Intermediate Bur oak, eastern white pine, northern red oak, red maple, sugar maple, sycamore, tuliptree, white ash
Resistant American sweetgum, arborvitae, black walnut, blue beech, catalpa, eastern hemlock, ginkgo, ironwood, Kentucky coffee tree, littleleaf linden, Norway maple, silver linden, swamp white oak, white oak

The same fact sheet explains why. Bark trapped in branch unions, dead or decaying branches, and a broad crown or fine branching that holds more ice all raise the risk. It says the strength of sound wood matters less than how well the branch unions hold.

Callery pear, which includes the ‘Bradford’ variety, is the species Ohio sources single out. Ohio State University Extension in Wayne County describes steep, V-notched branches that are prone to breaking off in ice, snow and wind. An Ohio State BYGL alert on an ice storm in the Cincinnati area says certain Callery pears such as ‘Bradford’ are notorious for weak stem attachments.

What are the warning signs on any species?

ISA’s Recognizing Tree Risk guide gives a checklist. A yes to any of these means the tree should be examined by an ISA Certified Arborist:

  • Large dead branches, or detached branches hanging in the crown.
  • Cracks or splits in the trunk or where branches attach.
  • Cavities or rotten wood in the trunk or major branches.
  • Mushrooms at the base of or under the tree.
  • Recent construction, a change in soil level, or new lawn or pavement.
  • A tree that has been topped or heavily pruned.

Purdue adds root signs to watch for: heaving soil, pulled or broken roots, and a leaning tree.

What can you do before the next storm?

Start with an inspection of the trees that could reach the house, driveway or service line. Purdue recommends structural pruning from a young age and removing dead, diseased and poorly attached branches, which is the purpose of preventive pruning.

Two things to avoid: Purdue says a tree should under no circumstances be topped to prevent wind or ice damage, and advises against trying to wind-proof a tree by thinning out its branches. Our guide to preparing trees for storm season has the full checklist. After a storm, read up on whether a storm-damaged tree can be saved before deciding on removal.

Storm-prone tree FAQs

Are silver maples likely to break in a storm?

Silver maple is on the susceptible side of the Illinois ice storm list. That rates the species as a group, not your tree. A silver maple with sound unions and no decay is a different case from one with a split fork over the roof.

Do oak trees hold up well in storms?

It varies by oak. On the Illinois ice storm list, white oak and swamp white oak are rated resistant, bur oak and northern red oak intermediate, and pin oak susceptible.

Does species matter more than condition?

The sources above put condition first. Decay, weak unions and root damage are the causes they name, and none of them is tied to a single species. Use the species lists to decide which trees to inspect first.

Sources

Need Help With a Tree?

Tell us about the job and get a free quote from our Toledo team.

Contact Us
PK Barmon
About the author:

PK Barmon researches and writes the tree care guides on Tree Services Toledo Ohio. Every guide is built from primary sources such as Ohio State University Extension, the City of Toledo and Ohio state agencies, and each one lists its sources so you can check them.