Quick answer: In an Ohio planned community, the default is that the association maintains trees on the common elements and each owner maintains trees on their own lot, unless the declaration says otherwise. Street trees in the tree lawn are a separate case: the City of Toledo treats them as city infrastructure and handles their pruning and removal. This is general information, not legal advice.
Most arguments about HOA trees come down to one question: whose ground is the trunk standing on? Once you know that, the governing documents and a few public rules settle most of the rest. Boards that want the work itself priced can look at commercial and HOA tree service in Toledo.
Who maintains which trees?
| Where the tree stands | Who maintains it by default | Where that comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Common area (entrance, pond edge, shared path) | The association | Ohio Revised Code 5312.08, unless the declaration says otherwise |
| An owner’s lot | That owner | Ohio Revised Code 5312.08, unless the declaration says otherwise |
| Tree lawn between curb and sidewalk, in Toledo | The City of Toledo | City of Toledo Street Trees FAQ |
| On the line between two properties | Both neighbors have an ownership interest | Ohio State University Extension (written for rural land) |
Who maintains common-area trees?
The association does, unless its declaration assigns the job differently. Ohio Revised Code 5312.08 makes the owners association responsible for reasonable maintenance, repair and replacement of the common elements.
Responsibility brings exposure. Writing about falling trees, Ohio State University Extension’s farm law office says a tree owner is possibly liable if they had knowledge that the tree was diseased, weak or patently dangerous. That is the reason for regular inspections and written records, which we cover under tree liability for commercial property owners in Ohio.
Who maintains trees on owners’ lots?
The lot owner, under the same statute, again unless the declaration says otherwise. Before you remove or plant a tree, read your declaration and association rules, because they can add requirements of their own.
For trees near a lot line, the Ohio State article gives these general points:
- You may trim branches that hang over your property, but you must use reasonable care. Causing disease or death of the tree could make you liable.
- When a tree stands on the boundary, both neighbors have ownership interests and both must agree before it is cut down.
- Ohio Revised Code 901.51 covers recklessly cutting or injuring trees on someone else’s land, with liability of three times the value of the damaged tree.
That article is written for rural property, and it notes there can be different laws for trees within a city or village. Association documents may differ too.
Who maintains street trees in the right-of-way?
In Toledo, the City does. The City of Toledo Street Trees FAQ describes the tree lawn as the strip of grass between the curb and the sidewalk, and calls street trees city infrastructure, like sewers and streets. Every property pays a Tree Maintenance Assessment that funds planting, pruning and removal.
The City says improper pruning, or removal without a permit, violates Toledo Municipal Code Chapter 917, and that there is no fee for a pruning permit. Maintenance concerns go to Engage Toledo at 419-936-2020. An association in another city or township should check that community’s own rules.
What should a written tree policy include?
Purdue Extension advises property managers to adopt a tree risk policy that sets a standard of care, an inspection process and a plan for dealing with risk. For an HOA, that usually means writing down:
- A map or list of common-area trees, and which trees are the City’s or an owner’s
- How often common-area trees are inspected. Purdue suggests at least every five years, every year in active-use areas, and after major storms
- How residents report a concern and how the board responds
- Rules for owners who want to remove, plant or prune near common areas
- Where inspection reports and work records are kept
For the fuller version, see what a commercial tree care plan includes.
Budgeting and contractors
Tree work belongs in the annual budget. Ohio Revised Code 5312.06 requires the board to adopt a yearly budget of estimated revenues and expenditures, with reserves adequate to repair and replace major capital items. A planned pruning and removal line is easier to defend than a surprise bill after a storm.
When you hire, the ODNR Division of Forestry’s tips on hiring an arborist say to get more than one written estimate and to ask to see liability insurance and a workers’ compensation certificate.
HOA tree policy FAQs
Who pays for HOA tree trimming?
By default the association pays for trees on common elements and the owner pays for trees on their lot. The declaration can change that split, so it is the first document to read.
Can an HOA remove a street tree in Toledo?
Not on its own. The City says removal without a permit violates Chapter 917, and that it only removes street trees that are dead, dying, diseased, hazardous or in conflict with required infrastructure repairs. Report the tree to Engage Toledo.
Can I trim a neighbor’s tree that hangs over my lot?
Ohio State University Extension says you may trim overhanging branches if you use reasonable care and do not harm the tree. Check your association’s rules first, and talk to an Ohio attorney if there is a dispute.
Sources
- Ohio Revised Code: Section 5312.08, Common elements; maintenance, repair and replacement
- Ohio Revised Code: Section 5312.06, Powers and duties of owner’s association
- City of Toledo: Street Trees FAQ
- Ohio State University Extension Farm Office: Trees near rural property boundaries, what are the laws?
- Purdue Extension: Tree Risk Management, What Every Property Owner Needs to Know
- ODNR Division of Forestry (hosted by the City of Centerville): Tips on Hiring an Arborist